Gresham’s Law is a fundamental economic principle that posits that when two forms of money with unequal intrinsic value are assigned the same legal tender value, the one with the lower intrinsic value (the “bad” money) will remain in circulation, while the more intrinsically valuable one (the “good” money) will be hoarded or otherwise withdrawn from active use.
Sir Thomas Gresham and the Origins of the Theory
While the concept itself dates back to ancient times, the law gets its name from Sir Thomas Gresham, a 16th-century English financier and economic advisor to Queen Elizabeth I. Gresham observed that when coins made of different metals were assigned the same face value, people tended to hoard coins with higher precious metal content and spend less valuable ones. While Gresham didn’t coin the phrase “bad money drives out good,” the phenomenon became indelibly associated with his observations.
How Gresham’s Law Works
Let’s break down the mechanisms behind Gresham’s Law:
- Perceived Value: When a government assigns the same legal value to two forms of currency with differing levels of intrinsic value (like gold vs. silver coins), people realize that the coin with higher intrinsic value is “worth more” outside of its official exchange role.
- Hoarding: This perception leads to hoarding. People either hold on to the “good” money as a store of value or melt it down for its raw material worth.
- Selective Spending: People will always naturally opt to spend the “bad” money first since it represents less value to them. This keeps the “bad” money in circulation.
- Disappearance of “Good” Money: As people continue to hoard or remove the “good” currency from circulation, it becomes increasingly scarce within the economy.
Historical Examples of Gresham’s Law
History is rife with examples where Gresham’s Law has played out:
- Bimetallism: In the 19th century, many countries had bimetallic standards, where their currency was backed by both gold and silver at a fixed exchange rate. However, if the market value of these metals changed, it would lead to one metal becoming overvalued in the currency system and Gresham’s Law kicking in.
- Debased Coinage: Throughout history, governments would sometimes debase their coinage by reducing the precious metal content while maintaining the same face value. The older, “better” coins would vanish from circulation due to their higher intrinsic value.
- Modern Fiat Currencies: While less directly applicable, some economists argue that Gresham’s Law can be observed in the context of fiat currencies (not backed by precious metals). If a government over-inflates its currency, eroding its value, people might turn to more stable foreign currencies or assets like gold.
- Ancient Rome: Rome provides a classic example of debased coinage. As the empire’s treasury dwindled, Roman emperors gradually decreased the silver content in their coins. This led to inflation, but it also exemplifies Gresham’s Law. The older, pure silver coins disappeared as people realized their greater value outside their role as currency.
- The United States (Pre-1965): Before 1965, U.S. dimes, quarters, and half-dollars were composed of 90% silver. When the price of silver rose above the point where the metal in these coins exceeded their face value, people started hoarding and melting them. As a result, silver coins vanished from circulation, and the U.S. switched to less valuable metals for coinage.
Important Note
In modern, fiat-based economies, the direct “bad money driving out good” dynamic is less pronounced due to absent fixed exchange rates and the fact that there generally isn’t an inherent value difference between different denominations of the same currency. However, the principle of Gresham’s Law still highlights how confidence and perceived stability are vital to a currency’s success.
Is Gresham’s Law Always True?
Gresham’s Law holds strong under certain conditions:
- Legal Tender Laws: The currencies must be legal tender, meaning the government mandates their acceptance for debts.
- Fixed Exchange Rate: A fixed exchange rate between the currencies is necessary for the disparity in perceived value to arise.
- Awareness: People need to be aware of the difference in intrinsic value between the two currencies.
Absolutely! While Gresham’s Law provides a valuable framework for understanding currency dynamics, it’s important to consider its criticisms and limitations:
Criticisms and Limitations
- Psychological Factors: Human behavior isn’t always perfectly rational. Habit, trust, and the lack of readily available alternatives can all influence people’s decisions about which money they utilize.
- Limited Applicability to Modern Fiat Currencies: Since modern fiat currencies don’t have direct ties to precious metals, the concept of “intrinsic value” becomes more abstract. While Gresham’s Law’s underlying principles still apply (people gravitate towards perceived stability), the classic “good vs. bad” currency dynamic is less straightforward.
Situations Where Gresham’s Law May Not Fully Apply
- Collectors’ Items vs. Circulating Currency: Older coins may have numismatic value far exceeding their intrinsic metal content. This collector’s premium negates Gresham’s Law as they’re no longer just competing currencies.
- Periods of Extreme Scarcity: In times of economic collapse or hyperinflation, any currency that can facilitate trade might be accepted, even if objectively considered “bad” by traditional standards.
- Black Markets and Informal Economies: Gresham’s Law largely assumes a legal market. In black markets, the perceived stability and acceptability of certain currencies might outweigh the classic notion of “intrinsic value.”
In Conclusion
Gresham’s Law is a valuable tool for understanding economic history and offers insights into currency behavior. However, it’s essential to remember that it functions best under specific conditions. The more complex and nuanced modern economic systems may exhibit scenarios where Gresham’s Law is less directly observable but its core principles regarding value perception and confidence remain relevant.
You may like this articles:
